Partner
If you’re stuck with a faulty vehicle, the last thing you want is to spend your free time in court. One of the most common questions we hear is, “Do I have to go to court for a lemon law case?” The short answer is: probably not. California’s lemon law is one of the strongest in the country, and in many situations, you can get a refund, replacement, or cash settlement without ever stepping into a courtroom.
What California’s Lemon Law Can Do for You
California’s lemon law, known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, protects drivers who buy or lease vehicles that don’t work the way they should. If your car has a warranty and keeps breaking down, even after multiple repair attempts, you might have a lemon law claim.
You may be entitled to:
- A refund of your down payment, monthly payments, and registration fees
- A replacement vehicle
- Reimbursement for repair costs, towing, or rental car expenses
These rights apply to both new and used vehicles that are still under warranty. The law puts the pressure on the manufacturer, not you.
When Court Isn’t Necessary
Most lemon law claims in California are resolved without ever going to trial. In fact, many never require filing a lawsuit at all. That’s because once we put the manufacturer on notice and provide the right documentation, they often agree to settle fairly.
Here’s how it often goes:
- We handle all communication with the manufacturer.
- We gather your repair records and confirm that your vehicle meets lemon law standards.
- We negotiate directly with the automaker for a refund, replacement, or fair cash offer.
Some manufacturers may offer arbitration, which is like a private version of court. Starting in 2025, California also added a new step for lemon law cases: mandatory mediation. If your claim hasn’t been resolved after you give the required 30-day notice, both sides must meet with a neutral third party to try to settle. Mediation usually takes place within a few months of filing and gives you a chance to resolve things without the time and stress of going to trial. Many cases are settled during this step.
When a Lawsuit Might Be the Best Option
There are times when the manufacturer refuses to take responsibility or lowballs their offer. When that happens, filing a lawsuit might be the best way to protect your rights. But even then, going to court doesn’t always mean a lengthy trial.
Here’s what often happens:
- We file the lawsuit in California civil court.
- The manufacturer takes the claim more seriously and returns to the table.
- Many lawsuits are resolved through settlement talks before a judge ever hears the case.
If your case does need to move forward, we’ll make sure you’re prepared.
What to Expect if Your Case Does Go to Court
Lemon law cases that end up in court usually involve more time, but that doesn’t mean more stress for you. We’ll handle the legal side while keeping you informed at every step.
If your case reaches court:
- You may be asked to give a short statement or appear at a hearing.
- We will manage all filings and responses.
- We handle any conversations with the opposing side.
- You remain in control. We’ll never agree to a settlement without your approval.
Also, under California law, the manufacturer may be responsible for covering your attorney’s fees if you win. That means we don’t get paid unless you do.
How We Can Help You Avoid Court
The key to avoiding court is building a strong case right from the start. At The Lemon Firm, we know how to do that. Our team has helped hundreds of California drivers get their money back or get into a better vehicle, often without setting foot in a courtroom.
We approach each case with the goal of reaching a fair outcome as quickly as possible. We know what automakers are looking for, and we show them that we’re ready to take legal action if necessary. With years of experience standing up to major manufacturers, our team brings confidence and persistence to every claim.
Get Started on Your Lemon Law Claim
Worried about going to court? You’re not alone. But with the right legal team, most lemon law cases are resolved before a lawsuit is even filed. We’ll review your situation at no cost and walk you through your options. Contact The Lemon Firm today to get started.